So Much, So Little Time

I wanted to take a moment to write a little about the Lesene chapter (6) in Adolescent Literacy: Turning Promise into Practice. I must first start by suggesting that everyone read this chapter, as it is jam-packed with useful information and valuable techniques.

First, I wanted to address the suggestion of graphic novels; this is a format that seems to be not only very popular but beneficial to the students. As Lesene will suggest throughout the chapter, we should focus on “multiple ways of knowing.” To clarify this, I will point to a quote that Lesene uses by Schwartz: “Graphic novels offer value, variety, and a new medium for literacy that acknowledges the impact of visuals. These novels appeal to young people, are useful across the curriculum, and offer diverse alternatives to traditional texts as well as other mass media” (67).

Not only is that true, but, as Lesene writes, “current curriculum demands that now include visual and/or media literacy can also be addressed with graphic novels and their variants from other countries. Graphic novels […] can contribute much to students’ understanding of how to go beyond a simple reporting of information to a more creative way of providing explanation” (67).

I did a big project last semester for YA Lit. in which I closely investigated the graphic novel format. I am convinced of it’s usefulness and would highly suggest it. I have a lot of information and books that I would love to share, if people are interested.

There are a lot of other important things in this chapter, some of which will have to be saved for the class discussion; however, I wanted to write briefly about censorship, another main part of this chapter.

Lesene tells us that “the new brutal realism in YA literature causes some to be concerned that these books are somehow not appropriate for adolescents” (75). Well, aren’t these brutally realistic depictions the same things that our students deal with each day. This brings me back to schools blocking the internet. If we block the things that students are going to use anyway, they will not learn how to use them appropriately. What if it is one of those “banned books” that has the ability to change a young adolescents’ life? Aren’t they going to go home and watch television anyway?

At least Lesene talks about the difference between censorship and selection. “Selection occurs when we make decisions about the books we are adding to our library collections. Selection takes into account the needs of the curriculum, the needs and interests of our students, and the need to have a balanced collection that represents all points of view” (76).

Censorship removes certain books from the students, and I know where I stand on that issue, right alongside of Lesene. However, it is important to understand the difference between selection and censorship.

Ray H.

Advertisements

2 Comments

Filed under Facilitation

2 responses to “So Much, So Little Time

  1. jillian24

    I can’t wait to have the censorship debate in class. I have a difficult time crediting a bureaucratic entity with any type of educational decisions, but I do agree that some books are inappropriate for some classrooms. Age, or more importantly maturity, should be a consideration. Yet, as teachers we know that maturity levels don’t always fit into grade levels. Making sure students are reading appropriate books is a teacher’s responsibility. If a bureaucrat has to label each book appropriate for certain grade levels , we’ll all end up teaching watered down books. Atwell also discusses book choices. She credits a parent’s right to prohibit certain books for their own children. That doesn’t mean that it gets removed from her library. She also conceeds, “if put to the test, I recognize when I can defend a title’s inclusion in our classroom library, and when I cannot” (34).
    Jillian

  2. canadawr5

    I am against censorship as it conflicts with my first amendment rights.
    On the brighter side, I think that graphic novels make reading more fun for student as it gives them the alternative from having to “visualize” the stories in their minds.
    Plus, it encourages many of them to become “active” readers.

    Ray Canada

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s