Christenbury: The Beginning

I really enjoyed the first three chapters of Christenbury’s Retracing the Journey. It is a quick read but also very rich. I was immediately impressed with Christenbury’s career history, which she detailed on page one, and includes working in a variety of educational settings. I only wish we could all be so lucky and have such a diverse background working with a wide range of students. I think this is a tremendous asset.

 

Further, in chapter 1 on page 3, I was reminded of Appleman’s discussions about theory in her book and how it disrupted the lives of her students, who, as I remember, were complaining about deconstruction. Christenbury writes about the parents of her students, who felt that their “children’s happiness was paramount” along with their “undisturbed sense of being” (3). This leads me to wonder if any of the kids in this school have been exposed to anything provocative and controversial in their ELA and/or other classes, since the goals of their families appear to be keeping them sheltered. Based on the student responses in chapter three about what they hope to learn in their English class with Christenbury, I assume that they have not been engaged in many meaningful activities. They view English class as many do: a place to read literature. No student mentioned exploring social issues or doing any exciting projects, which I was surprised about.

 

Christenbury feels more like a real person through her narrative than Gruwell did, and I think part of this is the fact that she allows us to read excerpts from her personal journal, which reveal her apprehensions, that I think we can all appreciate her bare honesty. Regardless of having been in the field for decades, she still discusses issues that I think we can all envision ourselves encountering. As oppose to meeting Stephen Spielberg, we will more likely than not be faced with poor school conditions, unenthusiastic kids, etc. I look forward to seeing where this story goes!

Mandy

Advertisements

1 Comment

Filed under Uncategorized

One response to “Christenbury: The Beginning

  1. sunyprof

    Mandy, I was hoping someone would post soon on Christenbury. I do find this a very useful book for us to consider toward the end of this semester. It’s a bookend in many ways to TEACH. And that was my intent for setting it up this way in the first place.

    The phrase that makes the most sense to me you quote here as well…re: students’ needing to maintain “an undisturbed sense of being.”

    I think that is what makes the work I do here so demanding. I disturb many students’ “sense of being” an English teacher in all those familiar ways that comfort and sustain us in our drive to pursue this profession.

    There is a huge price to be paid for disturbing the universe. Didn’t T.S. Eliot tell us that!!! KES

    P.S. I hope Jerry is reading–he will appreciate the literary reference.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s